Workflow vs Agent

In-depth interpretation of the differences between workflows and agents and their application scenarios.
Core content:
1. Definition and characteristics of workflows and agents
2. When to use workflows and when to use agents
3. The relationship between large models and agents and future development trends
What is a Workflow?
What is an Agent?
One agent = a combination of multiple workflows
The agent can be broken down into multiple subtasks, and each subtask may be a workflow.
When to use workflow and when to use agent?
Solve problems with workflows first and add agent autonomy only when necessary.
What's the use?
If the task can be performed with a standardized, fixed process, use a workflow, which is simpler, more efficient, more controllable, and more suitable for automated execution.
Intelligent agents should only be considered if the task requires flexible response to complex situations, but the computational cost of intelligent agents is higher and it is more difficult to control the results.
Whether you are making products, optimizing processes, or understanding the actual capabilities of AI, understanding the difference between the two can help you better plan solutions.
For example, the customer service system
99% of common questions (like “How do I get a refund?”) can be handled automatically with workflows.
However, when encountering emotional users, an intelligent agent is needed to judge and adjust the response method.
For example, internal automation in enterprises,
Workflow is suitable for approval processes, financial reimbursement, order processing, etc.
Intelligent agents are suitable for data analysis, intelligent recommendations, personalized customer service, etc.
It also helps to make smarter decisions and avoid detours, right?
other
Is the big model itself an agent? Is the agent the big model?
I don't think so. The current large model looks more like a brain. Do we need to add eyes, hands, and other things to it? After all, the intelligent agent has to do the work at the execution level.
Intelligent agent = brain + eyes (perception) + hands (execution) + memory (long-term knowledge) + feedback mechanism (optimization)
It must be a robot!
When the big model of the future develops to a certain stage, it will most likely be the intelligent agent itself. In that case, the intelligent agent is the big model itself.
So is the big model + MCP considered an intelligent agent?
If the large model fully internalizes MCP (i.e., it can manage multiple tasks, dynamically plan, adjust strategies, and collaborate like a multi-agent system), then it can be called an agent.
In other words, they are all "plug-ins" now. They are just a way to make LLM smarter, so they are not yet intelligent entities.
What is MCP?
To be honest, I am still confused about this thing. I will tell you after I experience more scenes...
Finally, I want to pass on the blame: our confusion is essentially that the word "Agent" has been abused.
PS: The first picture is a cat drawn by Midjourney, and the following pictures are from 4o and Claude3.7.